Skip to main content

Peer Review reports

From: Does the FNA sperm retrieval failure prediction model work well for current NOA individuals undertaking risk screening before the operation? Model validation, high-risk population identification and potential alternative sperm retrieval exploration

Original Submission
17 Nov 2023 Submitted Original manuscript
22 Nov 2023 Author responded Author comments - Yue Ma
Resubmission - Version 2
22 Nov 2023 Submitted Manuscript version 2
14 Feb 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report
24 Sep 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report
10 Oct 2024 Author responded Author comments - Yue Ma
Resubmission - Version 3
10 Oct 2024 Submitted Manuscript version 3
16 Oct 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report - Haitham Elbardisi
28 Oct 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report
11 Nov 2024 Author responded Author comments - Yue Ma
Resubmission - Version 4
11 Nov 2024 Submitted Manuscript version 4
15 Nov 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report
Resubmission - Version 5
Submitted Manuscript version 5
Publishing
10 Dec 2024 Editorially accepted
30 Dec 2024 Article published 10.1186/s12911-024-02816-5

You can find further information about peer review here.

Back to article page